Review: The Christmas Quandry by Shanna Hatfield

Posted December 20, 2021 by Lillian in Reviews / 0 Comments

Review: The Christmas Quandry by Shanna HatfieldThe Christmas Quandry by Shanna Hatfield
Series: Hardman Holidays #5
Published by Wholesome Hearts Publishing on 2016-11-10
Length: 283 pages
Reviewing Kindle from Amazon
Reading Challenges: 2021 Finishing the Series Reading Challenge, COYER 2021

Holiday surprises await two lonely hearts in Hardman

A sweet holiday romance from USA Today Bestselling Author Shanna Hatfield

Tom Grove just needs to survive a month at home while he recovers from a work injury. How bad can it be to return to Hardman for the holiday season? He arrives to discover his middle-aged parents acting like newlyweds, the school in need of a teacher, and the girl of his dreams already engaged.

After the loss of her parents and her fiancรฉ abandoning her to spend a year abroad, Lila Granger desires a change of scenery. She leaves her home in New York to spend a few months with relatives in Hardman, Oregon. The idea of stepping off the train into a place that gives her a true sense of coming home never entered her mind. Neither did the notion of falling in love with a man who clearly canโ€™t wait to get away from the small town.

The Christmas Quandary is a sweet Victorian romance, full of laughter and heartwarming moments, perfect for a holiday read.

The Christmas Quandry by Shanna Hatfield is the fifth installment of her historical series Hardman Holidays. I thoroughly enjoy this series and look forward to reading it each year. Itโ€™s an older series thatโ€™s been out for a while and is fully complete for those that like to binge read series ๐Ÿ˜‰ In this installment, we see a grown up Tom Grove find his happily ever after when he returns home for the Christmas holiday with a new character, Miss Lila Granger, Luke and Ginnyโ€™s younger cousin.

Tom is one of my favorite characters, and I was excited to realize this book was mostly from his POV. He is kind and empathetic to those around him. He genuinely has a good heart, and itโ€™s been fun seeing his character grow up during the series. The book starts with Tom arriving in Hardman after an on-the-job injury puts him out of work while he is healing. He canโ€™t exactly type a news article and chase down stories with a broken severely broken arm (crushed in the printing press). On arrival he finds that Alex and Arlan are expecting a new little one, and the pregnancy is taking a toll on her. Tom is asked to take over teaching duties until after the holidays when Alex should be feeling better, and there to help him is Lila.

I love Lila! She sees life as an adventure, and mischief constantly dances in her eyes. Itโ€™s easy to understand Tomโ€™s instant attraction to her. She reminds him of his own mother in her joy for life. Despite the hardships sheโ€™s faced in the last year (losing both her parents in a horrific accident), she meets each new day with a smile. The only problem is she is already engaged to another. Knowing there is no future for them, Tom tries (and fails) to put distance between them, but the heart wants what the heart wants. I loved seeing this relationship evolve from friendship to something more. The two characters are written so beautifully, and their heart ache and love shines through to the reader.

Overall, I loved The Christmas Quandry. Tom and Lila are easy to root for. The historical fiction piece is on the lighter side, yet it is still there. The authorโ€™s notes at the end of the book point out the liberties sheโ€™s taken as well as the true historical pieces. I highly recommend this one to anyone looking for a holiday romance.

About Shanna Hatfield

A hopeless romantic with a bit of sarcasm thrown in for good measure, Shanna Hatfield is an award-winning USA Today bestselling author of sweet romantic fiction written with a healthy dose of humor. In addition to blogging and a thing for dark chocolate, she is completely smitten with her husband, lovingly known as Captain Cavedweller.

Shanna creates character-driven romances with relatable heroes and heroines. Her historical westerns have been described as "reminiscent of the era captured by Bonanza and The Virginian" while her contemporary works have been called "laugh-out-loud funny, and a little heart-pumping sexy without being explicit in any way."

She is a member of Western Writers of America, Women Writing the West, Sweet Romance Reads, Pioneer Hearts, and Romance Writers of America.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Got a Reading Problem?

Get your fix here. Sign up today to receive new posts straight to your inbox daily!

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.